Tuesday, August 5, 2014

Human Variation and Race

Hot climates can be very detrimental to human homeostasis.  When exposed to heat for long periods of time, the human body can lose up to half a gallon of water each thirty minutes through sweating, resulting in rapid dehydration.  Heat exhaustion, the loss of bloodflow to the internal organs due to an increase of bloodflow to the skin, and heat stroke, where the body's internal thermostat stops functioning, both result from prolonged exposure to heat.  If these unhealthy effects are left untreated, this can cause the body's core temperature to pass a safe limit, resulting in hyperthermia.  This leads to the failure of the internal organs and potential death.

Four human adaptations in response to hot climates are:

  • A larger body surface area, which is a developmental adaptation.  According to the findings of biologist Joel Allen, mammal populations in warm climates near the equator had longer limbs than those living farther from the equator, in colder climates.  The same characteristics are found in human populations in the same regions; an example of this is the Samburu in Northern Kenya, who possess long limbs and a more linear body shape.  This is because a larger body surface area, created by longer limbs, allows humans to release larger amounts of body heat at a given time, so they can say cool in hotter climates.



 The Samburu (above) possess long limbs and linear bodies, providing a larger
bodily surface area from which excess heat can be released.


  • Sweating, which is a short term adaptation.  A period of sweating only lasts as long as the heat is present, and will stop once the climate has changed (and the external and internal temperatures have gone down).  This is also known as evaporative cooling, and while it is effective for short amounts of time, the water and minerals lost by sweating will eventually need to be replenished.



Sweating is essential to keeping the body cool in hot temperatures, especially
during periods of physical exertion.


  • The change of salt concentration within sweat, which is a facultative adaptation.  Once a person is exposed to high levels of heat for a long period of time, eventually the concentration of salt in their sweat will decrease, allowing it to last longer in their body, while the amount of water released through perspiration increases.


Although I don't have an image depicting the salt concentration within sweat, I gathered my information from the anthro.palomar.edu website, as well as one outside source.  Below is a graph from the Journal of Applied Physiology, which shows the findings of a study meant to "determine the effect of active heat acclimation on the sweat osmolality and sweat sodium ion concentration vs. sweat rate relationship in humans."  The study followed eight males over a 10-day period, who exercised each day in hot weather.  The graph shows that while the sodium ion concentration in their sweat decreased over the 10 days, the sweat rate increased.

Source: http://jap.physiology.org/content/103/3/990


  • The use of air conditioning and insulated shelter, which is a cultural adaptation.  This type of adaptation has nothing to do with the workings of the human body; however, shelter and conditioned air provide external barriers from heat.  A structure with an insulated roof and walls prevent heat from coming into the structure and cool air from escaping.  An air conditioning unit cools the air within the structure, allowing the body to cool down and maintain a proper temperature.


The ice blocks which make up igloos contain air pockets, which provide effective
insulation.  When warmed by body heat, the internal temperature of an igloo
can surpass the outside temperature by over 100 °F.



Air conditioning units collect air from outside a structure, cool it, and pipe it 
into the structure, producing an artificial climate inside.


By widely studying human variation, we can see the ways in which humans adapt to conditions, and in some cases how quickly they are able to adapt.  By using these findings, we are able to predict human evolutionary patterns resulting from certain environmental stresses.  In the case of heat acclimation, we can use the information gathered from people who are naturally more able to operate in a hotter climate, and use this information to create new technologies which help those who are not fit for these climates survive in them.


The idea of race comes from the physical differences expressed in humans.  Although we are all of the same species, we categorize ourselves by the shade of our skin, our facial structures, our body types, and so forth.  However, our real differences don’t stem from race itself—race is a byproduct of human adaptation.  Because groups of humans in different geographic locations managed to adapt to different environmental influences, their very appearances became different.  The variations resulting from a hot climate are a good example of these differences: those in hotter climates may develop a taller, more linear body structure to increase bodily surface area than those in colder climates, who may be shorter and stockier to retain body heat.  How these variations came to be, and the environmental conditions they are suited for, is a better way of mapping the differences between human populations than the variations themselves.  The decision to categorize people using these physical differences, these variations, is not scientific—it is a social decision, based on a desire for generalization.

4 comments:

  1. Great discussion on heat stress.

    Good explanation of the developmental adaptation of body shape. You did a very good job as well explaining the short term adaptation of sweating.

    Yes, salt concentration in sweat does decrease over time if the heat stress persists, but why? What is the advantage of having lower salt concentration in our sweat? Is there a down side to this in terms of body chemistry changes with higher electrolyte levels maintained in the body and not expressed in the sweat? No deductions on this, but you did a good job of exploring the science behind this and I just wanted to make sure you took it to its logical conclusion. Think it all the way through and make sure you answer the question of "why" 'this is adaptive.

    Great discussion on the benefits of the adaptive approach.

    " The decision to categorize people using these physical differences, these variations, is not scientific—it is a social decision, based on a desire for generalization."

    Perfect. Well said.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The differences in our subjects, since I wrote about the extreme cold, made this very interesting to read! Although I didn't write about igloos, the technological advances in insulation that make them useful was absolutely incredible to learn about in my own research as well!

    But in addition to the use of air conditioning and insulated shelters, I think something that's particularly amazing to note is the technological advances in clothing. For example, sports clothing retailer Under Armour advertises their HeatGear that not only wicks sweat away from the skin, but is also lightweight, breathable, and fast drying. Not meaning for this to sound like an advertisement for them, but I just find it really amazing what cultural advancements can be accomplished by better understanding the human body.

    I also really appreciate how succinct your analysis of race was because I had no idea where to go with the concept, so your thoughts have made me understand what the question was asking (even though now my post seems super incorrect haha). Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey !
    I wanted to comment your blog because I had rad Rachel's blog and hers is about the cold and yours is about the hot. In her blog she mentioned how african-americans can't survive in the cold because their limbs are too long and here you had said "According to the findings of biologist Joel Allen, mammal populations in warm climates near the equator had longer limbs than those living farther from the equator, in colder climates." So does this mean it is true ? I also found it interesting about the igloos, I always wondered how people who live in igloos stay warm, but it makes sense all the body heat in there warms it up, but at the same time, won't it melt the igloo ? Ahaha weird question. But I enjoyed reading your post along with Rachel's since it was opposite of each other.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If your talking about survival using any adaptation, those with darker skin and longer limbs may not have a natural advantage when it comes to the cold, but they could survive using cultural adaptations like warmer clothing.

      About igloos: not a weird question! They actually do melt on the inside, but it's at a very slow rate (it's not as if it's 70 degrees inside the igloo, it's about 45 degrees or so). When it snows, it produces another layer on the outside of the igloo, so it might become a little bigger over time.

      Delete